MAPS: Request map makers for help

Tips and tricks for the designers, playtests.

Moderator: Wonderdoctor

Post Reply
User avatar
randowe
Second Lieutenant
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 266
Joined: 2019-09-20 19:02, Friday
Location: Brunswick, Germany

MAPS: Request map makers for help

Post by randowe » 2019-09-22 10:05, Sunday

Feel free to discuss and ask for new maps in this thread.

Currently pending map requests i could find at JP's:
mythos wrote: - Khalkhin Gol (i'm not completely happy with existing maps)
- Zaoyang (no map)
- Changteh/Changde (i'm unhappy with existing map)
- Chongqing (i'm unhappy with existing map)
- Datong (existing map is small)
- Luding (existing map is small)
- Shanzi/Shanxi (its west of Beijing/Peking and as such would be of high interest to me - not sure about existing map)
- Tientsin (Urica made a great map - doesn't fit my ideas though)
REDrake wrote:I could really use a map of Saarbrucken or even Mainz.
Major Heinz wrote: Stalingrad Pocket (Map needed, the existing ones are not the map I needed)
Pocket of Minsk (The area of the pocket seems not to be not on a existing map)
Operation Doppelkopf (Map needed)
Tilsit Map
Siauliai Map
none wrote:Australia!..
Alice Springs
Kalgoorlie and its gold mine

Major Heinz
Private
Private
Posts: 48
Joined: 2019-09-21 16:12, Saturday
Location: Koblenz
Contact:

Re: Maps: Map requests

Post by Major Heinz » 2019-09-22 17:12, Sunday

Major Heinz wrote: Stalingrad Pocket (Map needed, the existing ones are not the map I needed)
Yes, a XXL Map with the City on the Right part of the map with enough room to deploy the Germans and soviets and on the left side there should be enough room to deploy core Units and a Frontline between the core and the City.
Major Heinz wrote:Operation Doppelkopf (Map needed)
There is no priority. In case of Need I can use Riga map.
Major Heinz wrote:Tilsit Map
Siauliai Map
Alternative it would be also great, if someone can make a XXL Baltic States Map with Saldus in the North, Tilsit in the south and Siauliai in the east.

A Mons Pocket map whould also be cool. Unfortunately there is only a german Wikipedia source for this battle https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessel_von_Mons
Edit:
Ok, Mons is not needed anymore. I was so stupid to look at the France Maps but Mons is in Belgium :bonk

User avatar
mythos
Second Lieutenant
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 115
Joined: 2019-09-30 19:37, Monday
Location: near a faerie forest in a misty vale

Re: MAPS: Request map makers for help

Post by mythos » 2019-11-07 19:31, Thursday

mythos wrote: - Khalkhin Gol (i'm not completely happy with existing maps)
- Zaoyang (no map)
- Changteh/Changde (i'm unhappy with existing map)
- Chongqing (i'm unhappy with existing map)
- Datong (existing map is small)
- Luding (existing map is small)
- Shanzi/Shanxi (its west of Beijing/Peking and as such would be of high interest to me - not sure about existing map)
- Tientsin (Urica made a great map - doesn't fit my ideas though)
Actaully, my wishlist is
- Khalkhin Gol and
- any 2-3 of [Zaoyang, Changteh, Chongqing, Datong or Luding]
for my Russian World Campaign.
I rather ask only for [Khalkhin Gol + 2-3 China maps], else the campagin becomes longer than i myself want to design - except someone is interested in a collaboration, i am not insisting to use FTL as the basis.

Khalkhin Gol would be great as a 3000px large map of the general area, for a large scale battle.
The others would be fine in more conservative sizes.


Major Heinz wrote: Stalingrad Pocket
Pocket of Minsk
Tilsit Map
Siauliai Map
Supported.

Stalingrad could even be XXL for a :monster scenario and/or 2-4 scenarios on this map for a Stalingrad Minicampaign (as standalone or within a bigger project). The tricky part about Stalingrad is however: a winterized version would be needed, too :notsure
Image

User avatar
randowe
Second Lieutenant
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 266
Joined: 2019-09-20 19:02, Friday
Location: Brunswick, Germany

Re: MAPS: Request map makers for help

Post by randowe » 2019-11-08 09:52, Friday

mythos wrote: Luding
How big should the map become? Have you seen photos of the bridge? I guess it looked even more fragile back in the days?
No vehicle, besides motorbike and Tuk Tuk, could ever cross it :huh

User avatar
mythos
Second Lieutenant
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 115
Joined: 2019-09-30 19:37, Monday
Location: near a faerie forest in a misty vale

Re: MAPS: Request map makers for help

Post by mythos » 2019-11-08 19:12, Friday

Hi Clemens :howdy

Thanks for bringing up the question: i hadn't touched the campaign path for months, and the last time that i thought about Chinese scenarios must be even longer ago. In retrospective, Luding probably only ended up on the list because the overall look was appealing (a traffic line running in north-south direction), however it is too far in the west.
Chongquing is also too far in the west - and a large urban area.
Tientsin is also a large urban area.
Shanxi is a province.

This leaves only the areas of
- Changde
- Zaoyang
- (maybe) Datong
on the Chinese part of my wishlist.

Sorry for the confusion :o
Image

Post Reply